COMMENT I have a lot of questions about Jefferies’ recent consideration to drop net asset value data from their research notes.
Does this signal a transformative shift in the real estate investment landscape?
This decision aligns customer demand and sentiments from several industry executives who believe that investors’ focus on NAV might be overemphasised. Will we see a growing inclination towards net operating income as a more reliable indicator of a property’s performance and value?
NOI offers a clearer picture of a property’s current operational performance. It’s all about the income generated from a property minus operating expenses (excluding taxes, interest, depreciation and amortisation). By focusing on NOI, investors get a better sense of the property’s profitability and cash flow potential, which are critical for making informed investment decisions.
This shift towards NOI is especially relevant for office buildings, which have faced significant valuation challenges. Traditional office buildings might be overvalued, particularly given the evolving work environment post-pandemic. With the rise of remote working and flexible working arrangements, the traditional office model has been under scrutiny, leading to questions about the sustainability of high NAVs in this sector.
Correction on the cards?
If Jefferies and other financial institutions start prioritising NOI over NAV, could we see a fundamental re-evaluation of office assets?
Properties once deemed overvalued based on NAV might see a correction, aligning more closely with their actual income-generating potential. This could potentially stabilise the market by providing more realistic valuations, which are less susceptible to market hype and more reflective of operational performance.
Under NAV, which looks forward at long-term guaranteed lease income, the actual performance of a building can be hidden. Lease payments continue even if utilisation is poor, masking potential issues with the property. In contrast, NOI provides almost real-time insight into how a building is performing by looking backwards at historical data and comparing it with current data. This transparency allows for more accurate assessments of a building’s operational success and immediate profitability.
Moreover, the experience factor that customers want today is often limited under the NAV model because more NOI generated from non-leasing income does not necessarily lead to higher NAVs. This limitation can stifle the office renaissance that is needed to meet customer demand and stabilise the markets.
Hospitality-led approach
This shift could also signal a renaissance for office spaces, driven by a hospitality-led approach to real estate.
Imagine office buildings not just as places to work, but as destinations that support great company cultures and where employees actually want to spend their time. By integrating hospitality elements – enhanced amenities, flexible leasing options and a focus on customer experience – investors can drive higher NOI through increased occupancy rates and customer satisfaction.
At Brave Corp, we believe this is the solution to the office problem. Creating these destination offices is about more than just the physical space; it’s about crafting experiences that support a vibrant company culture. When employees view their workplace as an exciting destination, it fosters a stronger connection to the company and enhances job satisfaction. This approach not only attracts and retains top talent but also extends the lifetime value of the customer by creating brand loyalty.
The emphasis on experience transforms the workplace into a powerful tool for building company culture. Offering amenities such as fitness centres, collaborative spaces, high-quality dining options and event programming can make the office an attractive place for employees to spend their time. This, in turn, boosts productivity, creativity and collaboration, contributing to the overall success of the business.
Positive culture
A well-curated workplace experience can significantly enhance customer retention and attract a broader range of occupants. This focus on customer experience drives higher NOI and makes properties more attractive to investors. Hospitality-led real estate strategies, which we set up Brave Corp to underwrite and deliver for our equity partners, therefore align the physical environment with the evolving needs and preferences of modern employees, fostering a positive work culture that extends beyond the office walls.
But it requires a different business plan for office strategies. As the industry adapts to these changes, several questions come to mind:
- Will the emphasis on NOI lead to more sustainable and realistic property valuations?
- How will this impact investment strategies and the overall attractiveness of office real estate?
- Will this signal the beginning of a broader industry trend towards operational performance metrics over traditional valuation methods?
- Will the business plan of office development change?
- Will value-add strategies be undertaken by permanent capital for long-hold vehicles?
- Could a shift to NOI make real estate investments more liquid by providing clearer, more immediate data on property performance?
The implications could be significant. A focus on NOI could redefine how success is measured in real estate, encouraging more adaptive and resilient business models. It could also prompt a re-evaluation of investment criteria, where the ability to generate consistent operational income takes precedence over speculative asset appreciation.
The potential move by Jefferies to downplay NAV in favour of NOI could mark a pivotal moment for the real estate industry, particularly for the office sector. By aligning valuations more closely with operational performance, the industry could foster a more sustainable and realistic investment environment. This shift could also pave the way for innovative approaches to office space utilisation, emphasising hospitality-led strategies that enhance customer experience and drive profitability.
As the industry evolves, creating office buildings that serve as destinations supporting great company cultures will be crucial for attracting and retaining top talent, extending customer lifetime value and building brand loyalty.
Caleb Parker is chief executive of Brave Corporation
Share your feedback
